Bring identity and mode evidence together Assign each actor to one class before deciding rights. Next distinguish permission-bit changes from ownership changes. For the helper, state one possible identity effect and one missing fact. Use only printed metadata; no privileged executable is supplied. Original printed case. Assume ordinary mode checks; no ACL/override; accessible parent paths. File: -rw-r----- analyst learners report.txt Actors: analyst (owner); mira (non-owner in learners); zoe (neither). Helper metadata: -rwsr-xr-x root root review-helper (no binary provided). Decide each actor's read/write rights; distinguish chown from chmod; identify the helper's review clue; explain why metadata alone does not prove exploitability or authorization to execute it.