Original fictional role card. Not an account on a real service. No sign-in was attempted. Worked case Account: member Sign-in: succeeded. The service recognized the account. Requested action: edit another member's record Server decision: denied The account is signed in, and this account may not edit that record. A button hidden on the page is not the decision. The server is. Activity matrix Account: rina Sign-in: succeeded Role: reader Read club notes: allowed Edit club notes: denied Edit the list of users: denied The role reader is only the actions this account needs. It is smaller than every action the service can perform. Check: edit club notes is denied.